Skip to main content

Multiracial Democracy is Young and Fragile

A brief history of the struggle to reconstitute a nation built on racial hierarchy around the principle of equality – Part I: Lessons from the rise and fall of Reconstruction

By Thomas Zimmer, May 6, 2026

An illustration from Harper’s Weekly from 1867: Black men voting in a state election in the South – credit: Hulton Archive/Getty Images

This is Part I of a two-part series on the history of multiracial democracy in America. Not a total history, of course, but something that can serve as a framework for how to think about this long struggle over how much democracy, and for whom, there should be in this country, the core dynamics that have shaped it, and the various stages and eras is has experienced.

Please support Democracy Americana!

Democracy Americana is a publication solely funded by readers.

Being an independent writer offers a lot of autonomy, which is a privilege. But it is also precarious and comes with lots of financial uncertainty. If you can become a paid member, please do. As a member, you receive many additional essays, and you gain access to the audio versions of everything I publish (members can find the audio at the end of the piece or available for download in the podcast player of your choice).

I need your support to continue this work. Thank you!

Not ready yet for a paid membership?

You can unlock this article for free by subscribing to the free version of this newsletter (via the registration wall below).

Before the Voting Rights Act of 1965, America was not a democracy. It was certainly not what we, in widely accepted parlance today, call “democracy.” It absolutely had no reasonable claim to be considered a multiracial democracy.

I know this may all sound awfully “political,” in the sense that it comes with a fairly straightforward partisan valence. But that is entirely a function of the fact that democracy itself has become a partisan issue, as the Republican Party is fully at war with pluralistic society and the principle of equal citizenship.

The Voting Rights Act set the United States on a path to becoming something that it had not been until the civil rights revolution of the 1960s: A multiracial, pluralistic democracy. And because the staunchly anti-egalitarian, anti-pluralistic forces that have always shaped the American story didn’t just vanish into thin air but instead engaged in a comprehensive countermobilization against modern democracy, the conflict over whether or not it should be allowed to endure and prosper has been the central fault line in U.S. politics ever since.

In that sense, and in that sense only, last week’s Supreme Court decision to essentially nullify what remained of the Voting Rights Act is helpful: It clarifies both the nature and the stakes of the political conflict. The question at the core of this struggle is this: Can a society built on racial hierarchy be transformed into a multiracial democracy? Or, put differently: Must America be forever defined by strict hierarchies of race, gender, religion, and wealth – or can the nation finally realize its promise of egalitarian pluralism?

The Roberts Court ends the Second Reconstruction

8 comments

Would you like to see the comments?
Become a member of Democracy Americana to join the discussion.
Become a member