Skip to main content

From the Declaration to Donald Trump

Wrestling with a history that is complicated, inspiring, frustrating, uplifting, and horrifying. A continuity of conflict, 1776-2026

By Thomas Zimmer, July 5, 2026

Before we start, let me remind you that I have launched a version of this newsletter in German. Same content, same analysis – only in German. If that is of interest to you, head over to Demokratie Americana (Opens in a new window) (where all pieces should be available within a few hours of publication on here). Please help me spread the word!

Also: Please support Democracy Americana!

Democracy Americana is a publication solely funded by readers.

Being an independent writer offers a lot of autonomy, which is a privilege. But it is also precarious and comes with lots of financial uncertainty. If you can become a paid member, please do. As a member, you receive many additional essays, and you gain access to the audio versions of everything I publish (members can find the audio at the end of the piece or available for download in the podcast player of your choice).

Not ready yet for a paid membership?

You can unlock this article for free by subscribing to the free version of this newsletter (via the registration wall below).

“American history is longer, larger, more various, more beautiful, and more terrible than anything anyone has ever said about it.”

I have used this quote several times before in my writing. I think about it a lot. It is from a speech James Baldwin delivered in October 1963, titled “A Talk to Teachers” (Opens in a new window). Baldwin was born in Harlem in 1924. His mother had fled the Jim Crow South. Baldwin himself left America as a young man in the late 1940s to flee the racist discrimination he experienced. For most of his adult life, France would remain his base; but often he returned to the United States to take part in the Black freedom struggle. Baldwin was a novelist and a poet, but also a political intellectual and civil rights activist. And he was a forceful, magnetic speaker. His perspective on U.S. history is among the most profoundly true and insightful things anyone has ever said about the United States. Anyone who works and thinks about America’s past, present, and future should adopt it as a guiding paradigm. And I believe it can also help us navigate this acutely perilous political moment in which we find ourselves right now. More various, more beautiful, more terrible. We need to grapple with all of these conflicting dimensions.

When big anniversaries came around, Americans at various points in the country’s history were asked to do a little bit of that grappling, perhaps; but mostly, they were invited to come together and celebrate the nation and its origins. In the past, such anniversaries tended to produce an outpouring of patriotic sentiment even after moments of immense strive – or perhaps precisely because these occasions seemed to justify papering over the cracks and the crises. That was an attractive proposition at least to those who were fortunate enough not to have their lives and livelihoods acutely threatened by the conflicts that continued to shape life in America.

In 1876, for instance, the United States celebrated its centennial a little over a decade after the most devastating war in the country’s history – a war fought within, against those who had betrayed the Union in service of what they believed was their right to enslave fellow human beings. As the celebrations took off, the South was officially still under military occupation. The attempt to impose biracial democracy in the former Confederacy was met with unspeakable levels of white supremacist violence. Out west, the U.S. army was fighting a brutal war to drive Native Americans off their land. And yet, at least white people in the North and the South displayed a patriotic spirit of reconciliation – eager to look forward, excited about the future. From May through November 1876, Philadelphia hosted the world’s fair and called it the Centennial Exposition (Opens in a new window): About ten million people, roughly twenty percent of the population, came to embrace the technological marvels on display.

In 1976, the United States was coming off a period of escalating political violence and assassinations, riots, mass protest. The nation had just suffered a humiliating defeat in Vietnam, struggling to understand the destructions and war crimes America had inflicted upon a far-away land, all in the name of defending freedom, somehow – sacrificing tens of thousands of their own young men in the process. Watergate was still casting a dark shadow over American politics, Nixon’s many abuses of presidential power had shaken the belief in the political institutions and the stability of the rule of law. And yet, America’s bicentennial – perhaps the largest celebration in the nation’s history – once again sparked a spirit of reconciliation. “We have inherited a great tradition,” President Gerald Ford declared (Opens in a new window), “but it is our job - older and younger people joining together - to see to it that when our ancestors (according to the National Archives, Ford really seems to have said “ancestors” and not “descendants” here? Hm.) meet here 100 years from now, they can say that what was done here on this date was the kick-off for a new century of unity, and progress, at home as well as abroad.” History as a call to unify around the shared American project and look towards the future in optimism.

This time around, however, in 2026 it is not working. America’s semiquincentennial is a bizarre spectacle, entirely overshadowed by the delusions and the authoritarian desires of a fundamentally ridiculous and profoundly dangerous man. Trump is utterly incapable of unifying, except around shared grievances directed at some “Other.” He spent the Fourth of July raging against enemies (Opens in a new window) real and imagined. Otherwise, he is mostly occupied with imposing vain projects of self-aggrandizement on the nation: His ballroom, the triumphal arch he wants to erect – a self-monumentalization fundamentally incompatible with a democratic Republic.

Most Americans don’t want to celebrate. Not with Trump, certainly. His “Great American State Fair” on the National Mall, a vehicle for deranged MAGA propaganda (Opens in a new window), has not been well attended, to put it mildly. And overall, the mood is not very patriotic, at least not by American standards. The percentage of people who say they are “extremely or very proud” to be an American has fallen, according to Gallup (Opens in a new window), from 85 twenty years ago to 53; if we isolate for people who say they are “extremely proud,” it has cratered from 59 percent in 2006 to merely 33 percent today.

And therein lies, potentially, one of the silver linings of the Trump era. What the country needs now is not some anniversary-induced nostalgia or unity based on willful ignorance. It needs a serious reckoning as the basis for what might hopefully be a new reconstruction. At the Quarter Millennium, Donald Trump is the President of the United States. And whatever else is true about the most powerful nation on earth, this fact alone forces a reckoning.

Contested ideals and the origins of a national struggle

1 comment

Would you like to see the comments?
Become a member of Democracy Americana to join the discussion.
Become a member