Skip to main content

Beware of the Normalizers and the Sanitizers

A lot of people are eager to declare the crisis over and quickly return to “normalcy.” That provides fertile ground for those who seek to launder rightwing extremism.

By Thomas Zimmer, November 21, 2026

credit: iStock / BreakingTheWalls

Please support Democracy Americana!

Democracy Americana is a publication solely funded by readers. If you are reading the free version of this newsletter, I sincerely appreciate your time and effort engaging with my work. Please share it widely to help me reach new readers.

Being an independent writer offers a lot of autonomy, which is a privilege. But it is also precarious and comes with lots of financial uncertainty. If your circumstances allow you to become a paid member, please do. As a paid member, you gain access to special benefits – including many additional essays and the chance to download the audio versions of all my pieces in podcast form.

A reminder: As part of Democracy Americana, I started a new podcast (Opens in a new window). Episode 1 is available wherever you get your podcasts. The next episode will come out in time for the Thanksgiving weekend. Please help me spread the word!

Without your support, I will not be able to continue this work. Please know that I am immensely grateful for your generosity!

Not ready yet for a paid membership? You can subscribe to the free version of the newsletter:

The moment the polls close, the outcome of the election is decided. But the second the first results come in, the struggle for what the election actually means begins. There is the actual election – and then there is “the election”: A collective understanding around what supposedly happened, how to interpret the result, and what lessons to draw from it. Election outcomes are immediately metabolized into messages. And those messages determine how the country moves forward, they shape the decisions of institutions and individuals alike.

The stakes in this struggle between competing narratives are really high. Take the example of the 2024 presidential election: Empirically, there is little doubt what actually happened. Trump won a narrow victory because (Opens in a new window) turnout among Democratic-leaning voters was down – and among the group of people who have no strong attachment to either party, an overwhelming anti-incumbent sentiment prevailed. But the dominant narrative, established within days of the election, told a very different tale: The 2024 election was a referendum that revealed the “will of the people”! America had undergone a major “realignment” and a “rightward shift”! This prevailing interpretation strongly suggested that the only reasonable thing to do was to accommodate the incoming MAGA regime. As a consequence, a climate of complicity took hold of the country’s political and media elite as well as its leading civic institutions. That was a major factor why the elite response to MAGA’s victory was initially characterized by a pervasive tendency to acquiesce and preemptively obey rather than oppose and resist. Those who pushed back against MAGA’s assertions of representing the “will of the people” and sought to fight against the authoritarian assault faced an uphill battle to dispel such notions that the election had bestowed upon MAGA the mandate to remake America in accordance with the Trumpist vision.

We are once again faced with a situation that requires we push back against narratives around the 2026 midterm elections that are not only diagnostically misleading, but politically harmful. It is the hour of the normalizers, the sanitizers, the launderers. See, democracy was never at risk! they assert with equal levels of confidence and dishonesty. See, there never was an authoritarian threat from the Right, it was all just liberal alarmism! And since Democrats won Mississippi, you better stop all this talk about racism too!

You might think such mendacious nonsense couldn’t possibly have a chance to convince anybody. But you’d be underestimating how much the American mainstream desires a return to “normalcy”: No more talk about the crisis of democracy, no more paying attention to rightwing extremism… it’s all rather uncomfortable, isn’t it? How convenient, then, that the election was (supposedly) all about “affordability.” Proper “normal” politics: Cost of living, the economy, stupid. No more need to talk about authoritarianism, mass deportation, ICE violence, and all that nasty corruption.

If we allow these narratives to take hold, they will undermine every effort to hold this corrupt, lawless government accountable. If the nation moves forward based on such an understanding of the midterms, it will become immeasurably more difficult to get Democratic elected officials to push for the kind of structural change the country so desperately needs.

Normalization in service of laundering the Right

Did the outcome of the election “prove” that democracy was never at risk to begin with, that the authoritarian threat was just a foolish chimera indulged by hysterical Libs who suffer from Trump Derangement Syndrome? This has long been the claim on the anti-liberal Right, especially among all those who don’t want to be perceived as openly pro-MAGA but are committed to an aggressive anti-anti-Trumpism.

The Wall Street Journal editorial board (Opens in a new window) offered the purest distillation of this particular blend the day after the election. All the talk about authoritarianism, “all the hyperventilating about what Mr. Trump might do,” was just, we are being told, “another partisan panic attack, promoted to gin up interest and enthusiasm.” No surprises here, since the Wall Street Journal has long paired its serious news coverage with an opinion section that exists as a playground for reactionary hacks. The “argument,” if we want to call it that, is obviously not worthy of serious consideration: Attacks on democracy are only bad if they successfully bring the system down. Otherwise, stop whining, Libs!

And yet, that is exactly the reaction we were being treated to from those same corners of the political spectrum in the spring when Hungarians managed to vote Victor Orbán out: Orbán, as Ross Douthat at the New York Times (Opens in a new window) (who has since switched over to Bari Weiss’ new gig) quickly declared, never was an authoritarian to begin with – everyone who called him that was just part of a Liberal witch hunt. Such statements either betray a child’s understanding of politics or a high level of disingenuousness. The latter is much more plausible. Douthat is simply sympathetic to Orbán’s illiberalism, just as the Wall Street Journal editorial board is sympathetic to the Right’s anti-liberal project. The goal, therefore, is to launder and normalize the Right – no authoritarians here, promise! – while discrediting what they deride as liberal “alarmism.”

Apparently, the Wall Street Journal is really determined to find out how far they can possibly push this attempt to use the outcome of the midterms in order to discredit anything they associate with “the Left.” Within the past week, they offered an editorial and an opinion piece claiming that “The midterm elections blow up Democratic myths about racism.” (Opens in a new window) Scott Colom’s victory in Mississippi, in particular, supposedly proves that systemic racism doesn’t exist (Opens in a new window). Check mate, Libs!

The Center desires normalcy

If such mendacious dishonesty from the anti-anti-Trump Right was all we had to worry about, there wouldn’t even be anything worth writing about. It’s all as predictable as it is disqualifying.

Unfortunately, these deliberate attempts to launder rightwing authoritarianism have a much better chance of seeping into the mainstream because the American center, broadly defined, so desires a return to “normalcy” and for the political emergency to be over that it might be willing to entertain what should obviously be discarded immediately.

On November 14, for instance, the New York Times published a piece written by Emily Bazelon titled “Perhaps the Rumors of Democracy’s Demise Were Premature.” (Opens in a new window) I will say that the article wasn’t as bad as the framing via the headline may have suggested. The author made the case that the midterms were a reminder that the Trump government hadn’t managed to overcome the resistance from the institutions, especially the courts, and a mobilizing civil society. However, in what is unfortunately typical New York Times fashion, this reasonable argument was somewhat buried underneath a whole lot of euphemisms (why does the paper of record insist on writing about “Trump’s hyperaggressive use of presidential power” when they are actually referring to an all-out assault on the rule of law and the constitution?) and false equivocating: The piece offers expert testimony from people who very much agree that the authoritarian threat has been real; but if you only read this article, you wouldn’t know that they basically represent what is close to academic consensus, because of course the author also found someone who thinks American democracy is doing just fine. In an attempt to signal “neutrality,” everything is dissolved into a one-person’s-word-against-another’s situation. The piece is lazy, more than anything else. There is no serious effort to assess the danger – or the damage already done. Nothing to make sure the message most people will receive isn’t exactly what the framing suggests: That it is certainly time to ask if all the talk about threats to democracy was overblown – and probably reasonable to assume it was.

On its own, this piece in the New York Times would unlikely have much of an effect. But it did not come out in vacuum. Normalizers, sanitizers, and launderers understand that now is their time. And unfortunately, mainstream media outlets are all too willing to provide them with a powerful platform. Just a few days after the Bazelon piece, for instance, the New York Times also published the musings of University of Chicago law professor (Opens in a new window) telling us that all the mean criticism of the Supreme Court needs to stop immediately because, actually, we should all be so grateful to the Roberts Court for its wonderfully independent competence. Time to enact court reform in order to rein in a rightwing majority on the Court that has acted as the spearhead of the reactionary mobilization against modern democracy? Oh no! Everything is fine, don’t you know, just carry on and revere this Supreme Court’s sublime guidance. It should be noted perhaps that William Baude, the author of this remarkable opinion, clerked for Chief Justice John Roberts in 2008-9.

 This piece is free to read for everyone.

But recently, only paywalled pieces have generated new memberships and thereby revenue. I am hoping we can buck the trend so that I can keep publishing free essays like this one regularly. That is crucial for the long-term viability of this publication, as it is the only way to achieve visibility and thereby reach new readers.

Please help me by supporting Democracy Americana with a membership:

(Willful) misunderstandings and deliberate distortions

The day after the election, an editor at a German political magazine asked me to write a piece about how, despite the result, Trump was not merely an accident. In that (sleep-deprived) moment, I didn’t quite see the connection between the outcome of the midterms and the need to reiterate that Trump’s rise was not merely some accidental departure. The man and his movement have dominated the Right and the Republican Party for over a decade. He is obviously himself the manifestation rather than the cause of longstanding anti-democratic radicalizations, and the extremist forces that united behind Trump in 2015/16 are evidently not going anywhere anytime soon. I now believe I didn’t quite get the assignment – or failed to see the chance it offered. I should have written that piece and tried to remind people why this isn’t over, why this was not some inconsequential blip, why the forces of extremism and the threat emanating from them were acutely real. Perhaps the editor sensed what I may have underestimated initially: How strong the sanitizing onslaught would be, how pervasive the desire for “normalcy” that provided an opening for those who seek to launder the authoritarian Right.

Since the election, I have experienced these tendencies and desires firsthand, in conversations with audiences at live events, in panel discussions, in interviews. At one particular event, the week after the election, I was confronted with the type of aggressive normalization of the political situation in the United States as well as an unabashed laundering of the MAGA movement and the Republican Party that I have not encountered since the early days of the second Trump presidency. This was an event in Germany, mind you. But German perceptions of American politics are shaped overwhelmingly by a news coverage that reflects a rather narrow corridor of opinion probably best described as the New York Times center. In many ways, what you are getting with the average German America discourse is, for better or worse, an unadulterated version of the polite society discourse in the U.S. And what I have been getting is a kind of emboldened effort to normalize. A particular segment of mainstream opinion is now aggressively insisting on taking us back to pre-2025 levels of downplaying and whitewashing the situation.

-       American democracy under threat? Don’t be ridiculous! – As if it was impossible to conceive of the political conflict beyond a simplistic binary of perfectly democratic vs full-on totalitarian, as if we hadn’t just spent two years popularizing the concept of “competitive authoritarianism” that rightfully emphasizes that space in-between a fully functioning, stable democracy and a consolidated autocracy.

-       Donald Trump, an authoritarian? What irresponsible alarmism! – As if we didn’t need to distinguish between Trump’s inability to impose his desires on the country on the one hand and his obvious authoritarian cravings on the other.

-       The GOP a rightwing extremist party? What leftist hysteria! – As if the MAGA movement wasn’t fully in control of the power centers and institutions of both the party and the broader conservative movement – a movement whose leaders couldn’t possibly be any clearer about the fact that they are at war with the very idea of a pluralistic democratic society of equal citizens.

There obviously was never a consensus around the nature of MAGA and the level of threat it represented, no shared understanding and acceptance of the fundamental reality of American politics: That only one of the two major parties, The Democratic Party, currently is a (small-d) democratic party – and that therefore a Democratic victory is unequivocally good for democracy in America. In the wake of the midterm elections, all those who have, for a variety of reasons, never been comfortable with accepting those parameters are leaping at the chance to reassert a different narrative.

Efforts to normalize meet a desire to sanitize

I am less interested in efforts by those on the Right – be they pro-MAGA or just anti-anti-Trump – who consider it their mission to launder rightwing authoritarianism. Their motives are all too transparent.

What concerns me most is how much those laundering efforts are gaining traction among the mainstream, how much fertile ground they find in the widespread yearning to return to a state of “normalcy,” to declare the crisis over, to impose a heavily sanitized and therefore more “comfortable” version of the political discourse. 

These normalizing, sanitizing desires manifest in many forms, some more easily decoded than others. There is, for instance, the pervasive tendency to insist that the midterm election was all about affordability. Paul Krugman wrote an appropriately angry column (Opens in a new window) just a few days ago about the eagerness with which people who should know better are adopting the affordability tale. No serious person disagrees that perceptions of the economy and the cost of living played a crucial role. And there certainly is a segment of the electorate for whom those concerns were the priority that determined their vote choice. But the evidence is indisputably clear (Opens in a new window) (and getting clearer every day (Opens in a new window)) that this isn’t the only and probably not even the main story. The election must be understood as a comprehensive repudiation of Trump and his government. And that very much includes the authoritarianism, the corruption, the ICE violence, the mass deportation, the cruel attacks on the rights and dignity of vulnerable minorities, the frontal assault on multiracial democracy via the dismantling of the civil rights era’s crucial legislative and institutional achievements.

But in the way the election is being metabolized by America’s mainstream outlets and commentators, you often find all those aspects relegated to a footnote, a side plot at best, while the affordability narrative overwhelms everything else. It was quite telling, for instance, how Ezra Klein, a bellwether of center-liberal elite opinion, even projected the affordability tale backwards onto the Obama presidency in his post-midterms reaction podcast (Opens in a new window). “In 2008, Barack Obama won a very big victory,” Klein declared. “But the unemployment rate continued to go up, and so 2010 was a historic wipeout for the Democratic Party. And that wasn’t because Obama’s personal style was repulsive to the electorate. He won in 2012. People liked him quite a bit. It’s because, fundamentally, if people do not feel their lives are getting better — in fact, they feel they’re getting worse.”

Once again, the point is not to deny that socio-economic factors played an important role in mobilizing a significant majority against Obama’s party in the 2010 midterms. But to tell that story without mentioning the racist, white nationalist fury that the American Right unleashed against the first Black president is odd. Just like the 2026 version of the affordability tale, it is an implausibly monocausal story that is weirdly sanitized. And that is precisely what makes it so attractive to the mainstream: It is a way to discuss American politics without having to center and properly grapple with all the “unsavory” stuff: the racism, the white nationalism, the extremism, the cruelty, the violence, the conspiratorialism, the lawlessness.

Want to support my work? Consider becoming a paid member:

It is not a coincidence that the sanitized affordability tale has significant overlap with the story leading Trumpists and their intellectual enablers on the Right have been pushing since the election. JD Vance (Opens in a new window) was quick to declare that it was all about the Iran war and the effects it’s had for the American consumer. Similarly, Christopher Caldwell, who probably has the most mainstream credibility among all the rightwing intellectuals who used to be all in on Trump and regularly gets to present his version of events to the readers of the New York Times, used the paper of record to tell a bizarre tale (Opens in a new window) in which Americans were fully on board with everything the government was doing in the first year in office but then turned on Trump because of the Iran war and not much else. The mass deportation, the paramilitary violence committed by ICE and Border Patrol, the rabid destruction of state capacity, the vile attempts to resegregate the institutions of state and civil society: In Caldwell’s utterly disingenuous presentation, that’s totally what the majority of the American people supported and would have continued to support if not for the Iran disaster and the way it made life more expensive in the United States as well as the lacking execution of an otherwise great program by a failing Trump. It’s not difficult to figure out what Caldwell wants to achieve: He is trying to establish a narrative that explains the wipeout the Republican Party just suffered as anything but an indictment and a repudiation of the far-right ideological agenda he himself supports. He is attempting to concoct a story that can salvage his idea of Trumpism and the assertion that “real America” is actually still behind it. If only we all go along with his story that blames it all on Trump himself who, as Caldwell puts it, “snatched defeat from the jaws of victory” because he suddenly gave in to “vanity, instability and foolishness.”

That is not the motivation that leads Ezra Klein and other mainstream commentators to indulge a similar “affordability and no need to talk about much else” narrative. The point is: The impulses that explain why the mainstream discourse is drawn to the sanitized “affordability” tale are providing fertile ground for the type of “democracy is fine/there never was an authoritarian threat/stop with the liberal alarmism/the MAGA agenda is actually popular” laundering that the Wall Street Journal and Christopher Caldwell are engaged in.

We are being reminded how fundamentally uncomfortable a lot of people across the mainstream spectrum of American politics have been with acknowledging the political reality of a deeply asymmetrical threat emanating predominantly from the anti-democratic radicalization of the Right and the extremist takeover of the Republican Party. This discomfort is particularly pronounced among establishment media, but we find it far beyond journalism in academia and civil society institutions as well. The idea that a “both sides” framing is the only acceptable approach to American politics is so deeply ingrained that being coerced into rooting for the Democratic Party by the fundamental realities of the political conflict has felt, to a lot of people who consider themselves to be “balanced” observers, just not quite right. They are eager to return to “normalcy.”

At the previously mentioned event the week after the election, the moderator – an American journalist – asked me why Democrats were so quick to focus on what he called “the blame game.” He meant the efforts to impeach Hegseth and potentially other members of Trump’s cabinet. The idea that Congress had a responsibility to use the tools provided by the Constitution to hold this administration accountable for the unprecedented lawlessness was entirely alien to him. The instinct was to apply “normal,” familiar-feeling categories: Silly politics, partisan shenanigans, typical Washington dysfunction. Faced with the enormity of the authoritarian assault since January 2025, it had become less convincing, less “respectable” to approach politics that way. But the desire to indulge in this sort of discourse never went away. We are finding out how many people and institutions are all too glad to accept any normalizing, sanitizing, laundering interpretation of the election that allows them to yet again indulge in the comfort of “normal” politics. They reflexively gravitate towards anything that is compatible with the “It’s the economy, stupid!” paradigm; they almost instinctively look for ways to undermine any interpretation that centers the struggle over democracy, authoritarianism, and extremism.

Why it matters

What is at stake here is not just whether or not we can agree on an empirically plausible interpretation of what happened in the midterms. The understanding that now forms around the election will determine how we move forward. It determines what efforts will be perceived as legitimate responses to the challenges America faces and what the mainstream discourse will deride as partisan overreach. It will either establish or undermine the political legitimacy of attempts to hold the MAGA government and its enablers accountable, describing them as either a necessary step to defend the rule of law – or a distracting form of “the blame game.” It will help legitimize efforts to finally enact the kind of structural changes to democratize the political system the county so desperately needs – or discredit them as a harmful threat to “unity” and the “balance” between Team Red and Team Blue. 

Don’t let the normalizers, sanitizers, and launderers dictate the path forward. There might be an opening for real progress, and such opportunities are rare in history. America simply cannot afford to waste it.

Thank you for reading!

Democracy Americana is my main source of income as an independent writer. Want to support my work? Consider becoming a paid member:

0 comments

Would you like to be the first to write a comment?
Become a member of Democracy Americana and start the conversation.
Become a member